After my mother died, my father moved her sister into our house — and Cassia made it clear from the start that I wasn’t welcome. Even with a broken arm and leg she still called me useless and expected me to run her wedding. Then my grandmother arrived with a “present,” and the two of them started shouting.
I was nineteen when Dad told me Cassia was moving in.
Mum had been gone ten months. There was still a dip in the couch cushion where she used to sit. There was still a mug at the back of the cupboard with a chip out of the rim that I could not make myself throw away.
Grief had turned that house into a museum of almosts.
So when Dad cleared his throat on a Tuesday morning and said, “Cassia’s going to stay with us for a while,” my brain filed it under temporary.
I was halfway through a bowl of cereal. “Stay. Like for the weekend?”
He kept his eyes on his coffee. “No. Indefinitely.”
“Why? She’s got her own flat.”
He breathed out slowly, like a man who had rehearsed it and found it still hurt. “She’s lonely. I’m lonely. It makes sense.”
“She’s my aunt, Dad. She’s Mum’s sister. Are you telling me you’re — together?”
Saying it out loud tasted like metal.
And he looked at me then, perfectly calm, and said: “Sometimes these things just happen. You’re too young to understand it now. One day you will.”
I wanted to scream that there were several billion people on this planet who were not my dead mother’s sister.
But grief had taught me something about my father, which is that once he decides, my feelings are admin.
So I rinsed my bowl. And I tried. I genuinely tried.
The first few weeks.
She arrived with three suitcases, a box of shoes, and a smile that could have been sold at a counter.
She hugged me in the hall, smelling of vanilla that was not vanilla.
“Oh, Marnie. Look at you. You’re the image of your mother at your age.”
That went through me like a skewer, but I smiled.
She wanted to be called Cassia. “We’re all adults now.”
And for about six weeks she was lovely.
When I had a bug in the May she brought soup up on a tray and told me off for trying to get up. When Dad was home she asked about his day and ironed his shirts and told him he ought to be proud of me for working and studying at once.
And I let myself believe we might manage it. Maybe this was what moving on looked like, and I was the one stuck in a house full of mugs.
The first time.
Two closing shifts back to back at the Kettle & Crumb. My feet were burning. I had put the basket of clean washing down by the couch and sat on it — the couch, not the basket — for ten minutes before doing the folding.
She came in in heels, on our own hardwood floor, at seven in the evening.
She looked at that basket for a full three seconds.
“Honestly. You’re as useless as your mother was.”
The room went very small. “What?”
“Don’t gape. Your mother was scattered. Sweet, but hopeless at anything practical. It’s no wonder you’ve picked it up.”
“Don’t talk about my mum like that.”
“You’re too sensitive, Marnie. Nobody else is going to tell you the truth, so it may as well be me.”
And she picked a blouse out of the basket, snapped it out, and walked off humming.
And that was the pattern for thirteen months.
When Dad was in the room: Marnie’s under so much pressure, we should be proud of her. A hand on my shoulder. A little smile like we shared something.
The second the garage door went: the nose-wrinkle at my room, the earbud pulled out of my ear, the sigh about the worktop.
And when she could not be bothered to be creative, the old one. You’re so useless.
That word follows you. It went off in my head when my alarm went at half five for an opening shift. It muttered at me when I submitted an essay. I started double-checking things I had done correctly for nineteen years.
I told Dad once.
She was out. The air was breathable.
“She’s different when you’re not here. She’s cruel. She talks about Mum like she was nothing.”
And his jaw did a thing. “Cassia? No. She’s been nothing but good to you.”
And the front door went, right on cue, and Cassia came in with bags and said “What’s wrong, sweetheart?” in a voice like warm syrup, and I looked at the two of them and understood exactly how the next four minutes would go.
“Nothing,” I said.
“Teenage moods,” she said lightly. “I remember those.”
I was nineteen and had a job and a student loan.
The wedding.
They got engaged in the August. Dad told me with a sort of awkward brightness, hoping I would at least pretend.
“We’re keeping it small,” Cassia said. “Intimate. But special.”
By we she meant me.
I did the venue at the Lark Rooms. The caterer. The flowers, twice, because she changed her mind. The order of service. The seating plan, which took four evenings and which she rearranged in fifteen minutes and then blamed me for.
“Don’t be useless, Marnie. You live here rent free. The least you can do is help.”
You live here rent free.
I want you to hold on to that sentence, because it comes back.
The stairs.
Three weeks before the wedding she fell down the back steps.
It was raining and she was in heels and she was carrying a box of favours, and she went down four steps and broke her left wrist in two places and her right ankle badly enough for surgery.
I was the one who found her. I was the one who rang for the ambulance and sat on wet concrete holding her head off the ground for eleven minutes, and she gripped my hand so hard she left marks.
And in the hospital, when the panic wore off, the first thing she said to my father was that the steps had been slippery because I had cleaned them wrong.
She came home in a cast to the elbow and a cast to the knee, in a wheelchair for six weeks, and she ran that wedding from a chair in the front room like a general.
Lists. Twenty-one days of lists. I was doing forty hours a week and my second-year exams.
And every day, at least once: Don’t be useless.
My grandmother.
Now. Nell.
Nell Rilke is my mother’s mother. She is seventy-five. She is also Cassia’s mother, and that matters more than anything else in this.
I had not seen her in nearly a year.
I thought she had stopped coming because of Dad and Cassia — because who wants to sit in the kitchen where her dead daughter used to sit, opposite the sister who took her place.
That is not what happened.
What happened is that Cassia told Nell, in the June, that I had asked for space. That I was struggling, that I had said Nell reminded me too much of Mum, and would she please not turn up unannounced because it set me back.
And Cassia told me that Nell had taken Dad’s side, was furious with all of us, and did not want contact.
Two lies, one to each of us, and we both believed them for eleven months, because the person telling them was the only bridge between us.
And it came apart in the April, four days before the wedding, because Nell Rilke walked into the Kettle & Crumb at half nine in the morning for a pot of tea and I came out of the back with a tray.
And she stood up so fast she knocked her chair over.
And the café, four days before, which is where it actually turned.
Nell knocked her chair over. I put the tray down on somebody else’s table and we stood in the middle of the Kettle & Crumb and neither of us said anything for about ten seconds.
And then she said: “You asked me not to come.”
And I said: “You said you were furious with all of us.”
And we sat down in the window with a pot of tea going cold between us and took the whole thing apart, sentence by sentence, for an hour and ten minutes, until we had both worked out that neither of us had ever said any of it.
See more on the next page
